Opinions please

I took this picture 5 exposures,1f increments, this is center exposure.


I ran it through Dynamic photo HDR a number of different ways, and while I liked the results, I wanted something a little different. I then took two of the results, layered them in PS and changed the opacity of one layer to end up with the following results.

1


2


Does anyone like the results?
If so why one over the other?
Has anyone done anything similar?
Do you think this is something worth pursuing?

Thanks for looking
Dick

Dick,

I like both, not really a favorite. The white balance is a lot different between the two, the first a little too warm, the second a little too cold. Put the white balance eyedropper on the snow, it should be neutral.

I'm not really sure about the composition to begin with. I think you should either show the whole barn, or get closer to bring out some of that great weathered wood detail.

I tend to agree w/ the above comment, Dick. The last photo is my favorite of the three, but I think the angle and comp are throwing me off a bit. Can't wait to see more, tho...

Melanie